Proof of citizenship requirements takes its toll on Oregon health care

The federal mania for ID requirements, manifest as a requirement that you prove US citizenship in order to get state health benefits to which the feds contribute, has apparently taken a bite out of the butt of the group most sane people predicted would be hurt by the new requirement: legal citizens fully eligible for the benefits.

From Oregon Live:

PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — According to a state report, more than 1,000 Oregonians have been denied access to health services under a new federal law that requires them to prove they are citizens.

State officials say they think almost all of the people affected are citizens. But they, or their parents, were unable or unwilling to round up all the required documents, according to a the recent report from the Oregon Department of Human Services.

The report looked at the experience of nearly 200,000 people in 125,000 Oregon families who had to prove their citizenship to get or retain state health services during the first six months the law was in effect — September 2006 through February 2007.

It found that 99 percent of them eventually were able to qualify, but that 1,011 Oregonians were cut out of state programs. Many of the people cut were children.

The law was designed to save money by ensuring that illegal immigrants do not get free health care on the government's tab. But an earlier Oregon study found that few noncitizens were receiving government-paid health care, and officials say few of the people denied coverage in Oregon under the new law are noncitizens.

Of those turned down for lack of proof, 91 percent came from English-speaking households, the report says. Only three Spanish-speaking adults were unable to document their citizenship.

The state tried to help people by checking Oregon birth certificates via computer for free. It also devoted thousands of hours to retraining employees and spent $44,000 buying certified copies of birth certificates and other documents from other states for applicants who could not afford them.

Do you mean to tell me that the federal lawmakers were unaware that a big chunk of US citizens does not run around with their certified birth certificates, and pretty much lacks the money and the knowledge to go about acquiring those birth certificates?